Tuesdays with Dorie: Oatmeal-Peanut-Chocolate Cookies

I passed on last week’s TWD recipe because I was all alone in the house and couldn’t justify making a big ice cream-ganache cake with only my lonesome to eat it, and my miserly self couldn’t justify using almost a dozen eggs and pounds of chocolate, only to gift the whole thing to friends. There you have it, folks–cheap and selfish. No apologies! However, this week I’ve returned to the TWD party, cookies in hand. But not just any cookies, we’re talking “Chunky Peanut Butter and Oatmeal Chocolate Chipsters.” (I think the title is bigger than some of the cookies.)

These cookies are a delicious Frankensteinian combination of oatmeal, peanut butter, and chocolate chip cookies. I like oatmeal cookies but I dislike raisins, so I rarely make traditional oatmeal cookies. Similarly, I like peanut butter cookies but they’re not my absolute favorite, so I don’t often make them for myself. But I luuurve chocolate chip cookies, so these babies seemed like the perfect combination of three American favorites. The peanut butter flavor is a little subtle, but I actually liked that, since it didn’t overwhelm the spices or chocolate. I made these right before taking a trip to visit family, and my brothers gobbled them up right away, sometimes two at a time. I’ll take that as a sign of success.

Although the taste was great, I think the texture could use a little work. Other people had gorgeous chunky cookie globes, while mine were fairly flat. I admit to a bit of cookie envy! I want to try and create the “chunky” cookie Dorie promised me–I love a cookie with heft and substantial thickness. I’ll be making these again soon, and again, until I get my perfect cookie.

13 Responses to Tuesdays with Dorie: Oatmeal-Peanut-Chocolate Cookies
  1. Rebecca says:

    These are sooooo easy to eat two at a time.

    My cookies have been puffier since I finally invested in Silpat. I thought I could get away with just parchment paper, but the Silpat makes all the difference in the world.

  2. Cathy says:

    Yours look so pretty — they don’t look flat in the pictures! Glad they were a big hit!

  3. n.o.e says:

    I like cookies just the way you made yours – not too puffy, not too flat, just right. Yep, me and Goldilocks! Great job with these.

  4. Clumbsy Cookie says:

    They look great to me, but if you want to repeat them that’s fine by me. Do you need help with the leftovers?

  5. Prudy says:

    I loved the comment you left me today-hilarious. Your cookies look great and I had fun reading your profile too. Great books on your list, and I’m with you about any book is great if it makes it worth it to stay up late.

  6. The DeL Sisters says:

    Your cookies look fine! We really liked them!

  7. A_and_N says:

    Frankensteinian combination…LOL :)
    The cookies look wonderful. And judos on the Eclairs. I am out of words to admire them!

  8. Barbara says:

    What nice pictures!

    I think chilling the dough really well before baking might help them be thicker. You could also try adding a bit more flour for a very thick dough.

  9. Pamela says:

    I think they look fantastic. Nicely done.

  10. Maria says:

    Your cookies look great. I think every cookie has character!! I love this recipe!

  11. Marthe says:

    Another great recipe from Dorie!!
    Mine were indeed quite chuncky, I didn’t pop the batter in the fridge though…

  12. CB says:

    I have chunky cookie envy too! I think next time I’ll ignore Dorie’s suggestion to flatten them before baking and see if I can get a more (preferable) rounded cookie ;)
    Clara @ iheartfood4thought

  13. Jaime says:

    they look great, even if they aren’t as puffy as you’d like!

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Oh Hello There
Don't Be A Stranger
Take Me Home Tonight
Hey sugar heroes!
My candy cookbook is available now from:

Barnes & Noble
Easter Desserts