Resolution Breaker Tollhouse Pie

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my disclosure policy for more information.

Happy New Year! Have you made your resolutions yet? Do any of them happen to involve healthier eating and/or weight loss? If so, you may want to stop reading now, because this month’s Pies With That challenge was all about creating a pie so tempting, it could only be called a resolution breaker.

It didn’t take me long to decide what kind of pie I wanted to make. For Christmas I received the Baked cookbook, and after hearing so many good things, I was anxious to try out a recipe. First to catch my eye was Tuscaloosa Tollhouse Pie, described as a cross between a pecan pie and a chocolate chip cookie.
*insert sound of record scratching*
I’m sorry, a pie that is also a cookie? HOW have I not heard about this until now? What other awesome dessert hybrids are on the loose without my knowledge? You had all better enlighten me, stat!

And with that, it was decided. In blatant disregard to my own personal fitness goals, I started my new year by having Tollhouse Pie and homemade Creme Fraiche Ice Cream for breakfast. We justified it by deciding that such a rich dessert was surely a sign of prosperity and happiness for the coming year! That IS how karma works, right?

The pie started out looking pretty homely. I made the pie crust, but it could easily be made using a purchased frozen crust. The recipe doesn’t state that it should be parbaked, but since I usually parbake the crust for my pecan pies, I went ahead and did a partial bake. Next time I might omit the step and see how it turns out. The batter itself is like a fairly thick cake batter–midway between a cookie dough and a liquidy pecan pie filling. It baked up puffed and golden brown, and smelled heavenly all during the baking.
Its appearance greatly improved once I cut a slice and topped it with a scoop of the creme fraiche ice cream, still soft from being freshly churned. (I think this is a pie that definitely needs a topping to cut the richness, either ice cream or lightly sweetened whipped cream.) I used macadamia nuts in place of walnuts, and next time I might throw some shredded coconut in as well, to make a tropical chocolate chip cookie pie.

And HERE is something crazy–just now, as I was typing up the recipe, I realized that I left out 1/2 cup of brown sugar from the pie! That’s fully half of the sugar the recipe calls for. This might explain why the filling wasn’t as gooey as I would have hoped. (Whoops.) However, it was still a great pie. The consistency was almost exactly like a soft, baked cookie. (And it definitely wasn’t lacking for sweetness.) I would like a little more goo, but Jason loved the cookie aspect, because, as he says, “Having a cookie in pie form makes it more socially acceptable to smother it with ice cream!” Well played, sir.

We both agreed that this was a pie worth breaking a resolution for. Wouldn’t you agree?

Check out the other sinfully good pies after January 6th on the You Want Pies With That blog. Want to ruin your own weight-loss efforts? Pie and ice cream recipes are below!

Resolution Breaker Tollhouse Pie

5 from 1 vote
This Resolution Breaker Tollhouse Pie is made from a batter that’s fairly thick- midway between a cookie dough and liquidy pecan pie filling. It baked up puffy and golden brown, and smelled heavenly all during the baking…also don’t forget the creme fraiche ice cream!
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 50 minutes
Total Time 1 hour
Yield 12
Calories 659 kcal


Tollhouse Pie

  • 1 pie crust, frozen
  • 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup dark brown sugar, firmly packed
  • 2 large eggs
  • 3/4 cup unsalted butter, (1.5 sticks), softened and cubed
  • 1 tbsp whiskey, (I omitted and added a little vanilla extract)
  • 3/4 cup walnuts, toasted and chopped (I subbed macadamia nuts)
  • 1.25 cups chocolate chips

Creme Fraiche Ice Cream

  • 2 cups heavy cream
  • 1/2 vanilla bean, split lengthwise
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 6 large egg yolks
  • 1 cup crème fraîche, (can sub sour cream with great results)


Tollhouse Pie

  • Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
  • Beat the eggs on high in a mixing bowl fitted with the whisk attachment. Beat until foamy, about 3 minutes. Switch to the paddle attachment, and add the flour and sugars. Beat for 2 minutes on high. Scrape down the bowl and add the butter, beating on high until well-combined. Scrape down the bowl and add the whiskey, and beat on high for 1 minute.
  • Fold the nuts and 1 cup of chocolate chips into the filling. Scrape into the prepared pie shell and smooth into an even layer. Sprinkle the remaining 1/4 cup chocolate chips on top. Bake for 40-50 minutes, covering the edges of the crust with foil if it gets too brown. The pie is done when it is puffed and golden brown, and a knife inserted into the center comes out clean.
  • Allow to cool before slicing, but this pie is best served warm, so heat slices for 20 seconds in the microwave before serving.

Creme Fraiche Ice Cream

  • Place cream in heavy large saucepan. Scrape in seeds from vanilla bean; add bean. Bring to boil. Remove from heat. Cover and let stand 15 minutes.
  • Using electric mixer, beat sugar and yolks in large bowl until thick and pale yellow, about 4 minutes. Gradually beat in warm cream mixture. Return mixture to saucepan. Stir over medium-low heat until custard thickens and leaves path on spoon when finger is drawn across, about 6 minutes (do not boil). Remove from heat. Cool 15 minutes. Discard vanilla bean. Whisk in crème fraîche. Cover and chill custard until cold, about 3 hours.
  • Process custard in ice cream maker according to manufacturer’s instructions. Transfer ice cream to covered container. Freeze until firm.

Recipe Notes

from Baked by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito


Our recipes are developed using weight measurements, and we highly recommend using a kitchen scale for baking whenever possible. However, if you prefer to use cups, volume measurements are provided as well. PLEASE NOTE: the adage “8 oz = 1 cup” is NOT true when speaking about weight, so don’t be concerned if the measurements don’t fit this formula.

Click here to learn more about baking measurements and conversion.


Calories: 659 kcal | Carbohydrates: 56 g | Protein: 7 g | Fat: 45 g | Saturated Fat: 24 g | Cholesterol: 222 mg | Sodium: 120 mg | Potassium: 143 mg | Fiber: 1 g | Sugar: 42 g | Vitamin A: 1270 IU | Vitamin C: 0.6 mg | Calcium: 105 mg | Iron: 1.5 mg
Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest
Editor's Note

This post may contain Amazon affiliate links. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, which is an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to  For more information, see my Disclaimer and Disclosure Policy.

You Might Also Like...

Leave a Review

Your comment will be visible after approval. Your email address will not be published.

Rate This Recipe!

What type of comment do you have?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • n.o.e wrote:
  • Clumbsy Cookie wrote:
  • Cathy wrote:
  • Megan wrote:
  • Linda wrote:
  • The Food Librarian wrote:
  • Tia wrote:
  • Carrie wrote:
  • Jude wrote:
  • Gretchen Noelle wrote:
  • Matt wrote:
  • Jodie wrote:
  • suz wrote: