Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies

Fact: everything is cuter in miniature size.

Fact: Miniature sizes mean miniature calories.

Fact: The “miniature calories” rule still applies when you take said cute miniature things and stuff them into giant cookies. Giant gooey, chocolatey, taste bud exploding-y cookies.

Facts don’t lie, right? I’m pretty sure that math adds up.

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

These ridiculous chocolate bombs are a riff on my Gooey Chocolate Cookies, which just might be my favorite cookie recipe ever. I often make them for events or parties, and I like to play around and swap out the nuts and chocolate chips in the original recipe for other mix-ins like toffee bits, pretzels, or chopped candy bars.

I was doing one such swap a few weeks ago, tweaking the batter, adding peanut butter, and throwing in reckless amounts of mini peanut butter cups, when it occurred to me that other people might want to hear about these variations, and see some melty chocolate food porn of the highest caliber. Other people like you. So here you go, friends! A feast for the eyes and the tongue:

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

 

I could give you a long spiel about why I added peanut butter cups to the batter, and talk about the complex flavor interplay between chocolate and peanut butter, and you could all play Food Blogger Bingo and try to see how many buzzword I crammed into one overly flowery paragraph.

The truth, though, is that I was at Fresh & Easy and all of their tubs of mini peanut butter cups were on clearance, and I’m the kind of terrible shopper who will buy things that I don’t need because they’re a good deal, and who knows when I might really need several pounds of peanut butter cups, and won’t I be sorry if I need them later and they’re more expensive? So long story short, I ended up with 4 containers of totally unnecessary peanut butter cups silently judging me from the cupboard. Tell me I’m not the only person who does this.

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

So when we were asked to bring cookies to an event recently, I was relieved that I could put the cups to good use and feel like I had done a good thing, a Smart Budget-y Thing, by buying all that candy. And not only am I the best budgetary ninja ever, but I’m the best cookie ninja ever, because this peanut butter cup variation is amazing. Think about it: what could possibly go better with gooey chocolate than pockets of gooey peanut butter cups? Nothing, that’s what.

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

I’ve written the word “gooey” approximately three dozen times in the post, so it should be obvious that this is not a dessert for the thin & crispy cookie fans out there. This is for the people who chronically underbake their cookies, seeking that underdone texture that borders on raw cookie dough. These cookies seem sturdy enough once they cool, but when you bite into them, the firm edges yield to a soft truffle center that will make you question if the cookie will hold up in your hand, or if you’ll have to resort to shoveling it in your mouth with a spoon.

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

The batter is made with a high proportion of chocolate—heck, it’s practically all chocolate—so definitely use a chocolate you enjoy eating! No bargain bin chocolate chips, please. [But bargain bin peanut butter cups? Don’t mind if I do.] Bon appetit, my gooey chocolate-loving chums!

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies | SugarHero.com

Recipe Notes: You can find miniature peanut butter cups at grocery stores like Trader Joe’s or Fresh & Easy, sold under the store brand. You can also look for Reese’s miniature peanut butter cups at grocery stores, drug stores, or online at Amazon. Alternately, you can chop up large peanut butter cups and stir those pieces in instead.

Click Here to Print or Email this Recipe!

Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
yield: 20 large cookies

3/4 cup all-purpose flour
1 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1 lb semi-sweet chocolate, coarsely chopped
1/3 cup (3 oz) creamy peanut butter
2 oz unsalted butter
1 3/4 cup packed brown sugar
4 large eggs, at room temperature
1 tbsp vanilla extract
2 cups mini peanut butter cups

In a small bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, and salt, and set aside.

Combine the chopped chocolate, the peanut butter, and the butter in a microwave-safe bowl, and microwave in 30-second increments until completely melted and smooth. Stir after every 30 seconds to prevent overheating. Let the mixture cool to lukewarm.

Place the sugar and eggs in the bowl of a large stand mixer, and beat with a whisk attachment until thick and foamy, about 5 minutes. Add the chocolate mixture and the vanilla, and mix them in until they’re incorporated. Scrape down the bottom and sides of the bowl, as the chocolate has a tendency to sink to the bottom.

Stir in the flour mixture, and when that’s incorporated, add the miniature peanut butter cups, reserving about 1/4 cup of them. Press a layer of cling wrap on top of the batter and refrigerate it until it’s firm enough to scoop, at least 1 hour. (The batter can be refrigerated for several days, but it will need to sit at room temperature to become workable if it has been chilled for an extended period.)

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F and line baking sheets with parchment paper. Use a large 1/4-cup scoop to scoop large portions onto the baking sheets. Cut the remaining peanut butter cups in half, and press a few of them on top of each cookie. Bake the cookies until they look dry and crackly on the top, but the center is still very jiggly and soft when pressed, about 12-15 minutes. Cool the cookies on the baking sheet—if you try to move them too soon, they’ll fall apart. Once cool, store the cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for 3-4 days For the best taste and texture, microwave them for a few seconds before serving, so the centers get warm and gooey.

 

If you don’t want to miss a SugarHero recipe, you can subscribe to get new posts by email, subscribe to the SugarHero RSS feed, become a fan on Facebook, or follow on Twitter. Ooh, and let’s not forget Pinterest. (I love Pinterest.) Thank you!

This post contains Amazon affiliate links. For more information, see my Affiliate and Advertising Policy.

37 Responses to Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
  1. Sarah says:

    Fact: I want to put this cookie in my face. Fact: impulse buying industrial quantities of candy is totally fine. Fact: I love saying fact before I say things. Fact: that is all :D.

  2. I’m so glad to know that I’m not alone in the “oh hey it’s on clearance so let’s buy this candy that I have no idea what I’m going to do with” camp. Seriously… I have bags of M&M’s that I just *needed* because they were on clearance but that had no grand plans. I’m thinking that those coconut ones are destined to meet an ooey gooey chocolate chip cookie because let’s face it.. ooey gooey is where it’s at!

    • Elizabeth says:

      I know! Seasonal M&Ms are the worst offenders! So cute and colorful, so totally unnecessary. I do have a soft spot for the coconut ones, though–also delicious in brownies!

  3. Marcia Schiffman says:

    My two favorite things in the world- peanut butter and chocolate- I think I’d like to marry these cookies!

  4. omg, Elizabeth, these look amazing! Now I need to find some mini peanut butter cups so I can make them. Like NOW.

    • Elizabeth says:

      Never fear, you can also chop up large peanut butter cups! I’d hate for anyone to miss out on these cookies because of a little thing like not being able to find mini cups.

  5. Danguole says:

    Definitely a soft cookie person over here! Most of the time, I don’t want to eat sweet crackers–PASS.

    I need to try some variant of these sometime, for sure. Saying something is your go-to carries a lot of weight with me, ya know?

    • Elizabeth says:

      Sweet crackers–exactly! Like, stop wasting my time with this crunchy stuff, and bring me your best underbaked cookie.

  6. I am the worst when it comes to grocery shopping because as soon as I see a deal on candy, I snatch it up. Whatever it is. Your a better women than I though by using your extra goodies in these cookies. Normally, I just shove the candy in the by handful.

    • Elizabeth says:

      I think my habit is actually worse, though, because instead of just eating candy I end up eating candy AND cookies. I’d be mad about it if it wasn’t such a delicious habit.

  7. Liz says:

    Love, love, love these and have to make ASAP! That’s a fact I know for sure! Glad to know I’m one of your gooey chocolate-loving chums…or else I wouldn’t have this recipe! :)

  8. Johlene says:

    My favourite is the 2nd photo!! Amazing recipe and photos!! Thanks for the comment on my Blog!

    Have a super week :-D

    XX

  9. Holy heck, these are absolutely perfect cookies! And yes, mini means mini calories, no matter where you put them! Pinned!

  10. So I see this picture on Pinterest and then I see the words gooey and cookie and I’m like, yeah, that’s good. Then I come to the post and I can’t stop drooling. Peanut butter cups are ALWAYS a good bargain buy and if you have extras, I’ll take them! I need these cookies so badly! Gooey chocolate peanut butter cookies? – Pinned!

    • Elizabeth says:

      Thanks Mary Francis! So glad to have another member of the gooey cookie club. (Um, wouldn’t that club have the BEST refreshments ever?!)

  11. I saw these on G+ and immediately jumped on over here.

    Oh. my. gosh.

    Incredible! And amazing pictures. Thanks for experimenting for us. :D

    And a pound of chocolate in the cookies? Plus two cups of peanut butter cups? Bahaha. LOVE this!

    • Elizabeth says:

      Haha, health food they are NOT. But at least you get some bang for your calorie buck!

      And isn’t G+ the best? I’ve found so many great food blogs and blogger friends through there!

  12. Kristjana says:

    Cookie ninja! I love it!

  13. These cookies are ridiculous! Everything perfect in one bite!

  14. I’m drooling as I read this post and look at these tempting photos!!!

  15. Camille says:

    Made these last night and they were so good. My friends came over and devoured them. This recipe is definitely a keeper.

  16. [...] from friends: Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies by Sugar Hero Reese’s Overload Cookie Layer Cakes by Back for Seconds Reese’s Monster [...]

  17. alex says:

    I just recently cleaned out my baking cabinet and found many of these bags of bargain candy you speak of..oops! forgot about them!
    would you like my mailing address? to send these to me??

  18. […] Filling – I Heart Eating Chewy Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies – Katie’s Cucina Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies – Sugar Hero Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies – I Heart Eating Peanut Butter […]

  19. Lisa says:

    This seems like a good reciepe to try so I am hope they turn out this is my first christmas baking cookies! It seemed a liitle intimidating but I managed. Just hope I don’t cause no sugar comas and or heart attacks cause I am making these as gifts for family and friends lol thank u 4 sharing! :-) happy holidays to u! Mwah! :-*

    • Elizabeth says:

      Haha, I’ll keep my fingers crossed for no heart attacks or sugar comas! So glad the dough worked out, Lisa, I hope you love the cookies! Happy holidays to you too!

  20. admattai says:

    I just made these cookies, and they are excellent! I made 1/4 of the recipe, and it made 8 decent sized cookies, baked at 350 degrees at 10 minutes. Thanks so much for the great recipe. The hardest part was waiting for the dough to chill for 1 hour :)

    • Elizabeth says:

      Awesome!! So glad you loved them! I agree, I’m all about instant gratification, so the waiting is killer. :)

  21. My God. Looking at your pictures and reading “gooey” for the 26th time, my mouth just started a chewing motion! Even weirder I was craving a glass of milk! What sort of witchcraft have you done to me?!?

    Amazing cookies! I wish I could make them but we’re still sour from the news of my son being allergic to peanuts :-(. You’d think he was being held ransom the way we were cursing peanuts and the allergy gods.

    But anyway, maybe one day I’ll make a small batch. These look too crazy to not make them. And high freaking five on getting all those peanut butter cups on clearance! I swear you’re like my blogging spirit animal. I don’t judge you at all!

  22. […] Gooey Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies, from SugarHero! […]

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Oh Hello There
Don't Be A Stranger
Take Me Home Tonight
Hey sugar heroes!
My candy cookbook is available now from:

Amazon
Barnes & Noble
IndieBound
Amazing Holiday Desserts