Chocolate-Pistachio Sandwich Cookies

Is it weird that I’m super into pistachios?

Pistachios are not trendy. They are not “having a moment.” They are not on anyone’s pop culture radar. Bacon? Bacon is still the foodie’s darling. Salted caramel is still going strong. Macarons are the new cupcake, and cupcakes are the old cupcake, which is to say: still popular. But pistachios? Nobody is showing the pistachio any love except me.

Fortunately, I have pistachio love to spare.


Random food trend tidbit: Let it be known that I predicted the rise of the retro dessert craze way back in 2009.You’re probably thinking I’m some kind of genius, and you’re not wrong. But I also predicted that the black and white cookie would explode, which it really hasn’t done…so I guess I’m only genius-adjacent. Or else 2013 will be the year of the black and white cookie. YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST.


But enough about me, let’s get back to the humble pistachio. I think this neglected nut is the perfect companion to these brownie-like chocolate cookies. They’re rich and fudgy, with pockets of melted dark chocolate chunks. They need to be paired with something that’s strong enough to balance our all that gooey chocolate, but won’t overpower it or fight with the flavor. Cue the pistachio’s entrance.


Pistachios actually appear in two ways in this cookie: as chunks in the cookies themselves, and as flavoring for the fluffy buttercream. That buttercream, by the way, is my dirty little secret. I was originally going to use pistachio paste to color and flavor it, but I was concerned about using a specialty ingredient that’s a bit uncommon and difficult to track down.

So instead, I used pistachio pudding mix to make the buttercream. Forgive me, food snobs, for I have sinned…but the pudding mix actually works really well! The buttercream is light and smooth, with a lovely pale green color and a vibrant pistachio taste. Scoff all you want, but it’s exactly what these cookies needed.

Finish them off with a coating of chopped salted pistachios around the edges, and you have a dessert that can compete against a bacon-salted caramel-macaron-topped cupcake anytime.


Black and white cookie, I’m coming for you next.

Click Here to View and Print this Recipe!

I’m all up in the internet! You can find me by subscribing to the SugarHero RSS feed, becoming a fan on Facebook, or following on Twitter. Ooh, and let’s not forget Pinterest. Thank you!
8 Responses to Chocolate-Pistachio Sandwich Cookies
  1. These look amazing Elizabeth!! I’m new to pistachio loving wagon but I’m here and loving it deeply!!

    Oh and it might make you happy to know that in the past week, I’ve “pinned” like 4 black and white cookies.

  2. Danguole says:

    Haha, again, you are in my brain… Or is it your brain? I can never tell anymore. All I know is, I totally have a pistachio idea written down somewhere that I can’t wait to try. Love them things!

  3. Casey says:

    Mmmm mmmmmm. Pistachio chocolate heaven.

  4. Heather says:

    It’s sad that I know this, but they played the black and white cookie episode of Seinfeld the night you did this post. Coincidence? Or do you and Mr. Seinfeld have a secret “taking over the world one two-toned cookie at a time” plot?

  5. Laura says:

    Love these cookies! And pistachios are definitely my favorite nut to make with (excluding peanut butter that is).

  6. Elizabeth McCrea says:

    I live in Georgia and am planning to make these to send to my friend in Florida for his birthday. Do you know if these will freeze? Or should they be ok if I’m going to send them overnight? I suppose I could ship them with some dry ice, but that’s kind of a pain.


    • Elizabeth says:

      Hi fellow Elizabeth!

      Admittedly I haven’t tried to freeze these cookies, but my guess would be that they’ll do fine. I’ve had good luck freezing other sandwich cookies with similar buttercreams, and I can’t think of a reason why it wouldn’t work with these. The only thing I would worry about would be if the cookies were smashed or otherwise damaged in transit, but with careful packing I think they’ll be great. What a lucky friend you have! Please let me know how they turn out. :)


Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Oh Hello There
Don't Be A Stranger
Take Me Home Tonight
Hey sugar heroes!
My candy cookbook is available now from:

Barnes & Noble
Easter Desserts