This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for more information.
So, what’s the consensus on the mustache fad? Are mustache accessories and jokes still funny? Totally over? Tired, but finishing one last lap around the pop culture track? And what about chocolate mustaches? Does the addition of chocolate change the answer at all?
I really, really hope you said that chocolate mustaches are still “in,” because, hey. I made you some cute chocolate mustaches for Father’s Day. Let’s eat, drink, and be mustached.
♥ LET'S BE DESSERT BESTIES! ♥
Sign up for the mailing list and become part of the SugarHero Squad. You'll get every recipe sent right to your email, plus first dibs on special offers, news, and more! Love you, mean it!
Our promise: no spam, just sweet sweet sugar.
I posted a recipe for Dude Food Bars earlier this week (if you missed them: bacon, pretzels, chips, caramel, and…go!) but I wanted to leave you with one more fast, easy, and cute Father’s Day idea, in case you’re doing some last-minute hustling.
Not sure what to get the dad or the husband? Want to show appreciation for the awesome men in your life? Mustaches are the answer! Whip up a few chocolate mustaches and make even the youngest gents happy…even if they’re not quite sure what to do with them:
Yeah, you know I made them dress alike for their mustache pictures…love these goofballs
I’ve seen mustache pop molds at stores like Michael’s and JoAnn’s, and that’s definitely one method of making chocolate mustache pops. But I really like making them freehand—it gives you more freedom to make the pops in exactly the size and shape you want, plus it’s easier to top them with sprinkles this way! And who wouldn’t want their chocolate mustaches to be covered with appetizing sprinkle stubble? Five o’clock shadow: it’s what’s for dessert.
I didn’t totally freehand the mustaches, though. I drew a template with several designs first, then put it underneath my work surface and traced the shapes. It’s easier, faster, and requires way less brain power. You can find all sorts of mustache inspiration by searching google images, or if you want to use the hand-drawn template I made, you can download the mustache pdf here.
To make these mustaches, I used tempered dark chocolate, and decorated them with a mix of milk and dark sprinkles. (I actually used some sprinkles I found at Cost Plus called De Ruyter, which the Dutch apparently eat on buttered bread for breakfast. I’ve obviously been doing breakfast wrong my entire life. Anyhow, they’re made with real chocolate and they’re delicious. Highly recommended.) Dutch sprinkles are definitely not required, and neither is tempered chocolate—you can use candy coating as a quick and convenient shortcut.
These chocolate mustache pops were fun to design and make, but even more fun to play with and pose with! Jason and I got into the spirit by hamming it up, while Asher mostly enjoyed trying to eat the chocolate as quickly as possible before I could get a good picture. (What can I say, he’s my son through and through.) It was like a game of cat and mouse, if the cat is wielding a chocolate-smeared camera and the mouse is twenty-five pounds of wriggle and teeth.
I’ve been talking about these in the context of Father’s Day, but they’d be equally good as party favors or shower treats. (In fact, chocolate mustaches were a favor at my own baby shower last year!) As the old saying goes, you can’t really go wrong with chocolate in the shape of facial hair.*
*Not really a saying
Full instructions are below, but here’s a quick visual tutorial so you can see how easy the whole process is. Happy mustache-ing!
Chocolate Mustache Pops
- 1 lb chocolate or chocolate candy coating
- Chocolate thermometer if tempering chocolate
- Squeeze bottle
- Mustache template link to pdf--optional
- Waxed paper
- 30 lollipop sticks
- Chocolate sprinkles optional
- If you’re using chocolate candy coating, melt it in the microwave in 30-second increments, stirring until it’s completely melted and smooth. If you’re tempering the chocolate, remove at least a quarter of the chocolate (about 4 oz) and set it aside—it doesn’t have to be a precise amount. Chop the remaining 3/4 chocolate into small pieces, and place in a microwave-safe bowl.
- Microwave the chopped chocolate in 30-second intervals, stirring after every 30 seconds. Once melted and smooth, insert the chocolate thermometer and make sure that it has reached a temperature of 115° Fahrenheit (46° C) on the thermometer. If it’s not close to that, heat it in short bursts until it reaches the right temperature.
- Add the reserved block of chocolate and stir it in. Continue to stir the chocolate frequently as the block of chocolate melts and the chocolate cools. When it reaches 90° F (32° C), test it to see if it’s in temper. Smear a bit of chocolate onto a piece of parchment. If it starts to set within a few minutes, your chocolate is in temper. If it remains wet-looking and does not set, continue to stir the chocolate and let it cool a few more degrees before testing again. Once tempered, remove any excess unmelted chocolate from the bowl and set aside to use at a later time.
- Fill the squeeze bottle with the prepared chocolate. If you’re using a template, put it on your work surface and cover it with a sheet of waxed paper. Using the squeeze bottle, trace around a mustache, then fill it in entirely with chocolate.
- Press a lollipop stick firmly into the side of the mustache, but not all the way on the outer tip, since it might be too fragile and breakable. Squeeze more chocolate on top of the stick and over the mustache so it is in a thick, even layer. If desired, scatter chocolate sprinkles on top while the chocolate is still wet.
- Gently and carefully shift the waxed paper to the side so that the template is in a different position, and trace another mustache. Repeat with more chocolate, filling the squeeze bottle as necessary, until all of your mustaches are made. If you used melted candy coating or tempered chocolate, those should set nicely at room temperature and can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature. Pops made from plain melted chocolate should set in the refrigerator and be stored there until ready to serve.