Don’t look at me like that. Haven’t you ever seen eyeball-shaped doughnut holes arrayed on a fur pelt before? Live a little, darlings.
See, what happened was that my doughnut holes were larger than expected after frying. (Story of my doughnut life.) So I decided that they weren’t just doughnut hole eyeballs, they were doughnut hole monster eyeballs. And from there it was just a short mental hop, skip, and jump to placing them on appropriately creepy monster fur. Mmm, synthetic hair…it’s what’s for dessert.
I don’t make doughnuts very often, and it’s a good thing I don’t. I’ve discovered that I love homemade doughnuts a little too much, if you know what I mean. I can’t remember the last time I bought a doughnut from a shop, but somehow when they were in my kitchen, fresh from the fryer and giving off those flirty doughnut smells, yeasty with just a bit of cinnamon, they were irresistible. Let’s just say my personal food pyramid had doughnut holes as the very bottom layer that day.
Full disclosure: this recipe makes a crazy amount of doughnut holes. Please, if you make this, I beg you to turn some into regular-sized doughnuts, otherwise you will have doughnut holes coming out of your ears. And we all know that doughnuts are meant to go into mouths, not out of ears. Get it right. On the plus side, it allowed me to make a mini doughnut mountain:
I want to go to there
Once the doughnuts were glazed and decorated, Jason and I had some fun shooting his hands in monstrous, eyeball-cradling poses. He would like you to know that he can do some really cool/gross tricks with his finger joints and he was holding back for the sake of art. In the end, I told him not to hold back any more and to let his inner monster out…
Oh yes, did I mention the doughnuts are filled? They’re filled! I used cherry pie filling (blended to the texture of chunky jam) because it has such a bright red color, but any sort of berry jam should work nicely.
The only real “specialty” ingredient you might need for these is white food coloring. It’s not necessary, taste-wise, but it’s what gives the doughnut glaze an actual white color, instead of just a translucent sheen. Americolor and Wilton’s both make white coloring, so between those, you should be able to find it at most cake/candy/craft stores. Your other option would be to use white candy coating, to give it more of a cake pop look. But I wanted mine to look like glazed doughnuts, dang it, so glazed doughnuts they were.
Happy Halloween, friends! May your doughnuts be filled, your eyeballs remain intact, and your monsters be hairy.
Recipe Notes: This recipe makes a lot of doughnut holes. Like, a crazy amount. You probably don’t need 100 doughnut holes. But halving it didn’t make sense with the ingredients—do you really want to measure out half of an egg? So you may want to make some doughnut holes and some regular doughnuts, so you’re not frying all morning long.
More ways to speed up this process: Instead of cutting out the circles, use a knife to cut the dough into strips and then squares. When they’re fried, they will puff up enough to be fairly round. They won’t be perfect, but my painstakingly cut circles didn’t turn out perfect either! Another idea is to omit the cherry filling step.
Finally, you can make these doughnuts in two parts, by making the dough in the evening, then refrigerating it overnight. It will rise in the refrigerator, and in the morning you can roll it out, cut it, and proceed from the second rise.
Doughnut Hole Monster Eyeballs
For the Doughnut Holes:
- 3/4 cup whole milk
- 1 tablespoon shortening
- 1.5 tablespoons butter
- 1 package 3/4 ounce active dry yeast
- 1/3 cup warm water
- 1 egg lightly beaten, at room temperature
- 1/4 cup granulated sugar
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 1 tsp ground cinnamon
- 11.5 ounces all-purpose flour about 2-1/2 cups, plus more for dusting
- 1 gallon vegetable or peanut oil for frying
To Fill and Assemble:
- 1 large can cherry pie filling can substitute 2 cups raspberry or strawberry jam
- 8 cups powdered sugar
- 3/4 cup milk
- 1 tbsp White food coloring very important for getting a white color!
- 2 packages Life Savers Gummies (7 oz each)
- 1/2 cup miniature chocolate chips
- Red food coloring
- Deep fry thermometer
To Make the Doughnut Holes:
- Warm the milk in a small saucepan on the stove just until it start to simmer. Place the shortening and butter in the bowl of a large stand mixer and pour the warm milk over them, letting the milk melt the shortening and butter.
- In a small bowl, combine the warm water (you’re looking for 95-105 degrees F, so it should be warmer than body temperature) and the packet of yeast, and mix briefly. Let it set for about 5 minutes, so the yeast can bloom.
- Once the milk has cooled to lukewarm and the yeast has bloomed, add the yeast to the large mixing bowl that contains the milk and butter/shortening. Then add the beaten egg, the sugar, the salt, the cinnamon, and half of the flour. (This will be 5-3/4 ounces, or about 1-1/4 cup). Use the paddle attachment and beat the mixture on medium speed for five minutes, until it’s very smooth.
- Now add the rest of the flour and, using the paddle again, beat for an additional 2 minutes until thick and smooth. Switch to the dough hook and beat the dough on medium speed for 5 minutes, until the dough forms a soft, smooth ball around the hook and pulls away from the sides of the bowl. If it seems a little sticky while it’s mixing, add a touch more flour, but only another tablespoon or two. Let the mixing do most of the work and resist the temptation to add too much flour, or else you will have tough doughnuts. When the dough is smooth, supple, and pulling away from the sides of the bowl, turn off the mixer.
- Generously oil a large bowl and turn the doughnut dough into the oiled bowl. Cover with a cloth and set it in a warm place to rise for 1 hour, until doubled in size.
- After an hour, dust your work surface with flour, punch down the dough, and turn it out onto your work surface. Roll it into a thin layer about 1/2-inch thick. Use a small round cookie cutter, about 1 inch wide, to cut circles out of the dough. Space the holes 2 inches apart on several baking sheets covered with parchment and lightly dusted with flour. Once you have cut out all the shapes you can, re-roll the dough and cut out more.
- Cover the sheets of doughnuts with a light cloth and let them rise for 30 minutes, until doubled in size.
- Heat the oil in a heavy pot or a deep fryer until it reaches 265 degrees Fahrenheit. You will definitely want to use a deep fry thermometer to monitor the temperature and make sure that it stays within the range of 260-270 F, so your doughnuts don’t cook too quickly or too slowly.
- Once the doughnuts have risen and the oil is the right temperature, gently place 6-7 doughnut holes at a time in the oil and fry them for 50-60 seconds per side, until they are puffed and golden brown. Once cooked, remove them from the oil using a slotted spoon or frying tool, and place them on a paper-towel lined baking sheet to cool. Repeat with the remaining doughnuts. If the oil gets too hot, turn the heat down, and if it gets too cool, pause your frying until it has a chance to heat up again. Let the doughnuts cool at room temperature for 30 minutes before filling them.
To Fill and Assemble:
- Blend the cherry pie filling in a blender or food processor, pulsing briefly, until it’s the texture of chunky jam.
- To fill the doughnuts, use a skewer or dowel to poke a hole in one end of the doughnuts, but don’t poke all the way through to the other side! Instead, wiggle the dowel around the center of the doughnut to make space for the filling. (If you have a Bismarck tip, the kind used for filling cupcakes, you can forget the dowel entirely and use that instead.)
- Fit a piping bag with a 1/4-inch round tip and fill it with your cherry pie mixture. Stick the tip in the hole that you’ve made and squeeze to fill the doughnuts. Stop squeezing when you start to encounter resistance, and remove the tip. If some filling leaks out, clean off the outside of the doughnuts before glazing and decorating them.
- Prepare the gummies: this sounds crazy, but I cut them in half sideways, so they wouldn’t be so tall and stick up obtrusively on the doughnuts. If you want to follow my insanity, use kitchen shears to cut the gummies in half.
- To make the glaze, whisk together the powdered sugar, milk, and white food coloring. (You may find it easiest to make several smaller batches instead of one big batch.) Whisk until no lumps of powdered sugar remain. It will be thicker than most doughnut glazes, but that’s necessary to get a white coating on the doughnuts. Use a fork to push a doughnut into the glaze until it’s submerged, then lift it from the glaze and let the excess drip back into the bowl. Set the dipped doughnut on a wide cooling rack set over waxed paper or parchment, to catch excess drips.
- Dip 4 or 5 more doughnuts, then, while the glaze is still wet, top each one with a gummy and push a miniature chocolate chip into the hole in the center of each gummy. Repeat this process until all of the doughnut holes are dipped and have eyeballs. Let set for at least 30 minutes to firm up the glaze. Cover remaining glaze with cling wrap pressed right on top to use later.
- When the glaze on the doughnuts has set to the touch, gently lift them from the rack and place them on a parchment or waxed paper-lined surface. Add red food coloring to the remaining glaze, and pour some of it into a paper cone or pastry bag fitted with a small #1 tip. (While you technically can use a plastic bag with a hole snipped in the corner, this is a job for precision and you will find it easier to pipe the red veins if you use a pastry bag or paper cone.) Pipe red blood veins on the sides of the eyeballs. Wait for the red to dry before moving and serving the eyeballs.
- Doughnut Eyeballs are best enjoyed fresh, the day they are made.
This post contains Amazon affiliate links. For more information, see my Affiliate and Advertising Policy.